top of page
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
Search

Told you Need Hip Surgery for FAI? Here's What to Try First:

Nov 2
6 min read


So you just left your doctor’s office after finally going in after having pain in your hip for months.  You’ve stopped training - or at least the way you want to - and you were hoping for answers on what’s going on.  What you got was a diagnosis of FAI, a quick explanation of the biomechanics, and a recommendation for surgery to fix the structure. 


While surgery sometimes is needed, immediately jumping to this as the only solution is problematic.  It’s missing the numerous factors that lead to pain and doesn’t take into account YOU and your history, beliefs, training routine, recovery, and other lifestyle factors.  The goal of this article is to help you understand a bit more about what FAI is, why imaging shouldn’t be the end all be all, and to show what good rehab can really do for you. Hopefully you’ll see that there’s a ton that can be done between “hey doc my hip hurts”, getting an MRI, and surgery being recommended…because in the majority of cases conservative management is the better option. 


What is FAI (Femoroacetabular Impingement)?


Generally, when you see an orthopedic doctor for hip pain, they’re going to look at the structural findings.  In other words they’re looking at if your imaging is showing bone, muscle, or other soft tissue changes.  


One possible finding is femoroacetabular impingement or FAI.  FAI is a hip condition where the femoral head and acetabulum (where your leg bone meets your hip bone) have malformations or deformities that may lead to increased force or contact through the joint.  There’s 2 primary types of FAI, cam or pincer morphology. 


A cam morphology occurs when there is an abnormality in the shape of the head of the femur.  A pincer lesion occurs when there is excess bone growth on the acetabular rim, which is the socket that the head of the femur sits in.  It is possible to have both types of FAI morphologies.  


These bony changes can then lead to abnormal movement at the joint between the femur and the hip socket (acetabulum), leading to impingement.  The stress then placed at the joint along with increased friction may lead to damage of the labrum (the ring of cartilage lining the socket that helps cushion and stabilize the joint).


What Imaging Misses


When these Imaging findings are present, it’s very important to remember that they do not tell the whole story in regards to why you’re having pain or limitations in function.  We don’t know when these changes occurred, at what rate they’re changing, and why pain or functional limitations are occurring NOW.  Even more importantly, they aren’t telling us anything about your loading capacity and what your body can actually do and tolerate.  


The research backs this up. A systematic review on 2114 asymptomatic hips found CAM deformity in 37%, pincer deformity in 67%, and labral injury in 68% of participants. This means that a majority of the people in this study had some type of FAI but do NOT have pain or limitations.  Similarly, a study on football players found labral tears in 78% of pain-free players and 70% of players with hip and/or groin pain, so labral tears were actually more common in the players without pain.  And yet another study found that symptom severity had minimal correlation with most impingement parameters and more to do with psychological and functional factors. 


So it really begs the question: are these structural variants more often incidental findings rather than the source of symptoms?


What to Try First 


Yes, I’m a physical therapist so I’m going to recommend PT first.  But I’m also someone who’s had FAI and a labral tear and resultant surgery (all before I was a PT) and know how I would do things differently if I had the chance. 


A good rehab program should be specific to you and your particular limitations, strength, and pain. As a physical therapist and strength coach, there are certain patterns that I often see emerge with people dealing with this type of hip pain. 


Addressing hip strength, particularly glute med and max early on is paramount.  Many people are strong through mid range but struggle at end ranges of hip extension.  Building up muscle capacity through these end range positions can be very helpful but also prudent to not push into end-ranges that are not tolerable. Hip flexion (bending the trunk closer to the thigh…..think squats, leg lifts, sit-ups) is often avoided by those with FAI as it increases their pain, but when the hip is ready this does need to be added back in to the programming so that tolerance and control can be rebuilt. Eccentric strengthening of the hip flexors generally is tolerated better as the entry-point to strengthening as it does not compress the front of the hip as much under load. 


As pain settles, continuing to build up capacity and tolerance to more dynamic movements needs to be part of the plan.  This is where I see many people struggle getting back to their sports because they missed this part.  They got their hip to calm down and they got stronger, but from there they were told to just ‘ease back in’ to their sport(s).  Progressions of lifting heavier, running, sprinting, cutting, jumping, or whatever else is required of your sport or activity needs to be part of the plan, not an afterthought. 


Why Most Rehab Fails People


It’s clear now that there’s a big difference between feeling better and actually back to the full capacity, tolerance, and confidence required to get back to your normal training.  What’s not always so obvious is why this happens even when you’ve been in physical therapy.  Here’s what I’ve found and why I’m so passionate about doing it differently: 


  • Insurance-allotted visits often run out right when someone's pain has settled but before they're sport-ready, so the progression gets handed off to "just ease back in" on your own

  • A lot of PTs simply aren't trained in strength and conditioning, especially past a certain point.  So they don't know how to build the progression even if they wanted to

  • Basic home programs don't deliver the dosage or progression needed to build tissue capacity…or confidence. Confidence in your abilities, in knowing you won't get hurt every time you push yourself, comes from reps of actually pushing yourself

  • There's rarely a clear benchmark or test used to decide someone's actually ready for their sport, so "you're done with PT" ends up being a guess based on visit count rather than capacity testing that looks like your sport


This has led one too many people to believe that they failed rehab.  What actually happened is rehab failed them.  Finding a physical therapist that understands strength and conditioning is vital.  So is going into that relationship with the understanding that this is going to take many months and hard work. 


Goals of Rehab 


Understanding what you’re working towards is what makes the months of hard work feel worth it, even during the boring or the hard middle parts that make us want to quit. 


The ultimate goal is improving load capacity using more functional metrics such as being able to walk farther, increases in squat strength or depth, more confidence and less fear around movements.  Confidence deserves to be on the list of goals in its own right, not just as a byproduct of getting stronger.  Research shows that psychological readiness plays a major role in whether someone actually returns to their sport (potentially even more than tissue capacity and strength!)  So you can build the tissue capacity to do something and still not do it, because you don't trust your body yet.


And confidence isn't built by being told you're ready — it's built through reps. The same repeated exposure that builds tissue tolerance is what teaches your nervous system the movement is safe again. That's exactly why the dosage matters so much, a program that never changes can't deliver that.


For these changes to occur, it’s going to take time.  So doing 6 weeks of banded PT exercises and then saying you ‘failed PT’ isn’t going to cut it.  To see actual changes in muscle strength it takes at least 8-12 weeks of progressive overload.  Eventually you’ll surpass what you can do with the band and if you don’t start working with weights and through different positions, it won’t meet the demand needed to get you back to activities such as barbell lifting, hiking, running, bouldering….etc. 


The Bottom Line


Zooming back out, here's what all of this comes down to: abnormal-looking hips are everywhere and mostly harmless. This is the same pattern we just talked about with confidence:  how much something hurts tracks better with psychological and functional factors than with what's visible on a scan. This is actually great news because it opens up so many more paths that can be taken to help you feel and move better.


Surgery is still a valid option, but rarely should it be the first step…and what happens between here and there is worth figuring out with an experienced PT and the rest of your care team, since it's nuanced and different for everyone.  The great news is that even if surgery does become the next best option, you’re putting yourself in a better place to recover by going into surgery strong and healthy. 


A structured, supported, and progressive rehab plan can help improve symptoms and function for those dealing with FAI or labral tears.  If you’ve recently been dealing with hip pain or told you have structural changes in your hip and you’re not sure what to do next, that's exactly what I help people work through at Adapt Movement & Rehab in-person in Seattle or with remote coaching worldwide.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page